Tuesday, August 02, 2005

A Postscript to Yesterday’s Post

By the way, Florida’s Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 1.730(b) [Completion of Mediation; Agreement] and Florida’s Family Law Rules of Procedure, Rule 12.740(f)(1) [Family Mediation; Report on Agreement] provide that the agreement reached in mediation is required to be signed by the parties and their counsel, if any.

The Rules of Civil Procedure identify 3 ways to memorialize an agreement:
  • Reduce it to writing
  • Electronically recorded [transcript filed with the court]
  • Stenographically recorded [transcript filed with the court]
The Florida Family Law Rules of Procedure likewise identify 3 ways to memorialize an agreement:
  • Reduce it to writing
  • Electronically recorded [made under oath or affirmed; transcript filed with the court]
  • Stenographically recorded [made under oath or affirmed; transcript filed with the court]
So, how is it possible that mediation notes, even coupled with testimony, could conceivably rise to the level of an enforceable mediation agreement? Do the Rules mean what they say – or not? Maybe my mantra, Nothing is as it seems nor is it otherwise, actually is a truism. The requirements of the Rules were not mentioned in the opinion. Hmmm!!

What do you think?

To email me, click Perry S. Itkin.